NYY/SF

[Yankees GM (Trevor)]

Yankees send Edwin Diaz, RP NYM ($1.00 ARB ARB)

Giants send pick 2.11.

Yankees accept, I simply like the pick over the player here, although if Díaz returns to his Seattle form, I lose big time. Regardless, that’s a risk I’m willing to take.

[Giants GM (Devon)]

I accept.

Here's to hoping Diaz gets his shit together. I'll take the upside over the pick.

[DBacks GM (David)]

I get Trevor's rationale for the trade but a mid 2nd for a young, controllable closer who is at his lowest value seems pretty light. Granted he had a terrible season last year but to assume that would be his new normal is hard for me to believe. He has plenty of time to turn it around and a mid 2nd round pick just seems too light to me.

Veto (0-1)

[Angels GM (Sean)]

Approve
(1-1)
I get it maybe could have got more but there are players left in the draft that will absolutely be more valuable than any reliever

[Deleted]

Approve (2-1)

[Blue Jays GM (Matt)]

Not franchise ruining, probably not the best trade, but I'll approve 3-1

[Padres GM (Fridge)]

approve .. id rather have a gamble at draft than diaz .. (4-1)

[Pirates GM (Alex)]

Wow. The odds of someone at 2.11 having a career like Diaz are much lower than Diaz returning to form. This is a steal for the Giants. But people get hyped on the draft every year and overpay for picks... Approve.

[Marlins GM (Andrew)]

pick is 2.12. same difference

updated